Divorce doesn’t have to be a prisoner’s dilemma

If you’ve been close to someone going through a divorce, you’ve probably heard some version of “I don’t have any leverage here.” And in a desperate search for leverage, extreme positions harden and threats get bigger. It can look like an arms race. But it’s actually a pretty predictable move in what game theorists call the “prisoner’s dilemma.”

Game theory is the study of how people make choices when the outcome of the choice depends on what someone else chooses to do. The prisoner’s dilemma is probably the best-known example from game theory.

It works like this. Two partners in crime (P1 and P2) are arrested and questioned in separate rooms. They cannot talk to each other or know what the other will do. The police give them both the same offers: P1 testifies and P2 stays quiet, P2 testifies and P1 stays quiet, both testify, or both stay quiet. Both not testifying means they both get a short sentence. Both testifying means they both get a medium sentence. One testifying and the other not testifying means the testifier goes free and the holdout gets a long prison sentence.

The best outcome for both of them (in game theory speak) is for neither to testify. But the position of not testifying if the other does is the riskiest – the long prison sentence for one and the other going free. And testifying is tempting no matter what the other does – if your partner stays quiet, you go free. What happens under these circumstances is often that both testify and so both get a medium sentence (a suboptimal outcome for both). If they had trusted the other one and both kept quiet, they’d reach the optimal outcome of both getting a short sentence.

There is a decent amount of scholarly work applying this to divorce and family law, from law reviews to bar journals to mediation publications. I’m not sure that the concept has made it out of the ivory towers and into our society’s view of divorce, though.

Two ideas run through this research that Rebecca and I strongly believe in: (1) human cooperation in any transaction depends heavily on whether the parties believe that they are in an ongoing relationship where they will continue to have to cooperate (what political scientist Robert Axelrod calls the “shadow of the future”) and (2) the role of advisors to the parties in the transaction, particularly the attorneys.

On the first point, it is easy to see why a divorcing couple would take the position that there will not be future cooperation and so act accordingly during the divorce – the marriage is over, after all. Per Axelrod: “If you know when the game is going to end, you defect right from the beginning.” It’s why positions so often ratchet up as the divorce decision gets closer, and why the spouse who feels they have no leverage reaches for more.

But with kids, this view is untrue. The romantic relationship is ending but the co-parenting relationship will continue, often for the rest of their lives. Rebecca and I spend time educating the couple at the beginning of our process to reframe their thinking here. This is not an ending – it is a transition. And for the co-parenting component of the relationship, this is a beginning. A chance to build structure and trust.

On the second point, attorneys and other advisors in the divorce process can play a large and sometimes outsized role in how the process will go. Litigious attorneys on both sides raise each spouse’s fear that the other will make a contentious move first – drain the joint account, file for an early restraining order, hire the “shark” – so each feels pressure to make it first.

Mnookin and Kornhauser’s classic Yale Law Journal article on divorce bargaining describes a parent willing to feign a custody fight “simply to intimidate a risk-averse mother into settling for less money.” A close friend or family member who went through a bad, high-conflict divorce might say “you need to stand up for yourself in there.”

Rebecca and I do the opposite. We tell clients right at the beginning this is about cooperation, and both spouses put that commitment in writing in a divorce mission statement – for example, that respect means not using threats during negotiations. We reduce their fear through education and communication improvement. We create off-ramps and release valves when the pressure gets too high or one spouse acts out. In the prisoner’s dilemma fact pattern, we take the spouses out of their separate rooms.

In a divorce with kids, the sentence in the prisoner’s dilemma isn’t just for the two spouses. It’s for the kids too. Remember, it isn’t divorce that damages kids – it’s prolonged exposure to parental conflict. So we provide both spouses the confidence they need to not escalate, which minimizes the conflict for the entire family.

Next
Next

I’m divorcing this person…why would I ever trust them again?